Methodology

How we rank menopause supplements

One published, points-based rubric applied the same way to all 27 products. Scores are calculated by a script from the research data, not adjusted by hand afterwards.

Last updated

The rubric (100 points)

CriterionPointsHow it's scored
Evidence40Editorial points for the best-supported ingredient at a studied dose, plus credit for product-level trials. Trials run or paid for by the seller count for less. Every product's points and reason are listed below.
NSF-verified testing2020 if we found the product in NSF's public registry (NSF/ANSI 173 contents certification or NSF Certified for Sport). 8 if the brand claims third-party testing we could not verify. 4 otherwise.
Value2020 × √(cheapest $/day ÷ this product's $/day). The cheapest product ($0.40/day) gets 20. Cost per day = regular one-time price ÷ days the container lasts at the label dose.
Ingredients102 points per listed active ingredient, up to 10. This rewards fuller formulas; it does not mean more ingredients work better.
Amazon rating1010 × (stars − 3) ÷ 2, scaled down when there are fewer than 10,000 ratings (× log10(count) ÷ 4). 4 points when there is no Amazon star rating.

Ingredient evidence grades

Caveats from our evidence review:

Evidence points for every product

Reason
Centrum Menopause Support Complete Multivitamin + Hot Flash Support24genistein 30 mg (below the 54 mg studied)
The 'Pause Nutrition MenoMulti26genistein 54 mg (trial dose)
One A Day Women's Menopause Formula26soy isoflavones 60 mg
Thorne Perimenopause Complete25EstroG-100 514 mg (trial dose) + hops
Remifemin Menopause Relief32iCR black cohosh; own RCTs (n=304, n=244)
Estroven Menopause Relief + Weight Management26soy isoflavones 56 mg + black cohosh 40 mg; no product trial
Nature's Bounty Optimal Solutions Advanced Menopause Relief29ERr 731 4 mg + affron saffron (mood)
Estroven Complete Multi-Symptom Menopause Relief27ERr 731 at the trial dose (4 mg); no Estroven-specific trial
Amberen Perimenopause22succinate blend; open-label trial only
Nature's Way Black Cohosh Premium Extract20black cohosh extract 2.5%, no product trial
Amberen Multi-Symptom Menopause Relief25own trials (n=125, pooled n=227), all manufacturer-linked
O Positiv MENO Menopause Gummies21KSM-66 ashwagandha 300 mg + black cohosh 40 mg
OLLY Mellow Menopause25EstroG-100 514 mg + GABA; own trial, sponsor-funded
Estroven Complete Menopause Relief Gummies27ERr 731 4 mg; no product trial
Ritual Perimenopause Health8evening primrose oil and DIM: no good evidence
Happy V Menopause Relief AM + PM22pollen extract + genistein 40 mg; no product trial
AZO Menopause Relief Daytime Gummies24genistein 30 mg
Bonafide Relizen25pollen extract; one small product trial (n=39) + Femal RCT
Kindra MenoRelief21Pycnogenol 100 mg + maca
Equelle Menopause Multi-Symptom Relief25S-equol 10 mg; own trials, one without placebo, sponsor-funded
MenoLabs MenoFit14probiotics: weak evidence
Wile Perimenopause Support14chaste tree, alfalfa, fennel: weak evidence
Stripes The Inside Addition18ashwagandha 300 mg
Womaness Me.No.Pause.17Pycnogenol 60 mg (below studied doses), low-dose ashwagandha
BB Company Provitalize12probiotics + turmeric: weak evidence
Gaia Herbs Menopause Support Daytime18black cohosh herb (not iCR extract)
Bonafide Thermella8curcumin/green tea not studied for hot flashes in RCTs

Prices

Regular one-time price on official brand site; if no DTC, Amazon/retailer list price (noted). price_per_day = price_one_time / days_per_container at label dose.. Prices were checked on November 19, 2026, while some Black Friday promotions were live; we used regular prices, not sale prices.

Ratings

Amazon star ratings and counts were read from each product's Amazon listing on November 19, 2026. Ratings measure buyer satisfaction, not clinical effect, and can mix reviews of related products.

Certifications

We only mark a certification as verified when we found the product in the certifier's public registry. Everything else is labeled a brand claim, and anything we could not confirm is labeled unverified.

How we write about effects

Dietary supplements may describe effects on normal body function (“structure/function” claims) but not on disease. We describe ingredients as “studied for” or “researched for” occasional hot flashes, sleep or mood associated with menopause, report trial facts (who, dose, duration, result vs placebo, funder), and never say a supplement treats a disease, replaces hormone therapy or is safe after breast cancer.

What's included and what isn't

Most visible US menopause/perimenopause supplements (non-Rx). Products we looked at but did not include:

Limits

*These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. These products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. Solynes does not sell supplements; descriptions summarize published research and are not medical advice.